Skip to content

The lead was for a tax return. The firm keeps the monthly books.

A name comes in, and it sounds like business. Then you find out they want a tax return, and the firm on your website keeps the monthly books.

An empty chair and a quiet desk phone in a small office at the end of the day.
The call already happened. The work it asked for may not be yours.A small office with the chair empty and the laptop closed.

The phone rings on a Tuesday that was supposed to be for closes. The person on the line is polite, ready, and a little proud of having found you. They want this year's return done, and they were told you could get them a refund. You keep the monthly books for owner-run companies. You stopped taking one-time returns on purpose. Nobody in the conversation is being difficult. The ad said accounting, and accounting was wide enough to mean both of you.

That is the part lead help tends to skip. The inquiry shows up already shaped by whatever was said to get the person to call. If that sentence is wider than the firm on your website, you spend the week being kind to people you cannot take. If the sentence promises a result you would never put on your own page, you have a second problem. The person heard it as coming from you.

Key Takeaways

  • A lead is not a client yet. It is someone who heard a sentence about your firm.
  • If that sentence is broader than the work you want, the calls will be too.
  • Read the message before it goes out. If you would not sign it, do not let anyone send it in your name.
  • You still decide who gets a meeting. A time on the calendar is not the same as a yes.

What the stranger was told

Ask to see the message. The email, the ad, the text, the page they landed on. Read it the way they did, once, without translating it back into your own vocabulary.

You are listening for three things. Who they think you serve. What they think you will do for them. What they think happens if they raise a hand. If any of those is news to you, the campaign is describing a different firm, and that firm is wearing your name.

"We help businesses with their accounting" will bring you the monthly close, the shoebox cleanup, the one-time return, and the person who wants a number for what they will save. Your site, if it is doing its job, already picked one of those. A page that says full service and then makes the owner guess is how the week gets lost. The accounting firms page is about drawing that line on the site before anyone else draws it for you.

Three matching folders beside a slot, and a pile of mismatched shapes that do not fit.
The work you named has a shape. A lot of what gets called accounting does not.
Matching folders next to a slot, and a pile of shapes that will not go in.
The work you named has a shape. A lot of what gets called accounting does not.

When the pitch becomes yours

It is tempting to file this under the vendor's problem. For tax work in front of the IRS, it is also yours. Circular 230 says a practitioner may not take part in a solicitation that is false, misleading, or deceptive, and may not accept help from someone they know is bringing clients in that way. That is 31 CFR 10.30. The IRS says the same thing more plainly in its FAQ for tax professionals, and it tells you to check the rules of the state where you are licensed.

A lot of those state rules follow the AICPA's advertising rule. You don't get to promise a favorable result, and you don't get to let someone else promise it and then take the client. The Code's note on third-party promotions says the member has to look, because you are not allowed to do through another person what you are not allowed to do yourself. The edition checked for this article is the 2014 Code. Your board may be on a later one. Ask if you are unsure. This page is not that answer.

Two questions come out of that, and there isn't one national reply.

  • If someone is going to call or text for you, ask how that person agreed to hear from you. Have your own adviser look at the answer before the first call.
  • If the helper is paid only when you accept the client, ask your board whether that fee is a commission or a referral you have to disclose or turn down. A price per name and a price per signed client are different conversations.

A smaller way to find out

You do not need a quarter's worth of names to learn whether this is working. You need a handful you can read on a Thursday.

Agree the sentence first. Who you take, what you lead with, who you turn away. Then read the actual message. If you would wince to see it on your own site, it does not go out. When the handful arrives, set each one next to that sentence before anyone puts a meeting on the calendar. Keep going only if the next handful looks like the work you wanted. Stop when it drifts, and fix the message before you ask for more.

The one that wastes the most time is the one that is almost right. The task is close and the entity is wrong, or they want advice when you lead with the books. Say no, or point them toward a path that has room. If you stretch the offer so this one can count, the next batch will aim at the stretch.

You still say yes

None of this hands the meeting to the helper. Someone at the firm reads the note and decides. The helper does not keep the books, prepare the return, or sit in the advisory conversation unless that was a separate agreement you meant to make.

Before you ask for a bigger pile, take one real inquiry and lay two notes next to each other. What the stranger was told. What your staff think the meeting is for. If those notes name different work, you are not ready for more of them.

When the pitch is really about a neighboring practice, financial and professional services is the wider map. When you want the message and the firm to describe the same work, speak with us. Bring the sentence on your site and the script. The useful part of the conversation is the gap between them.

Conclusion

Lead help fails in an ordinary way. Something true gets said too broadly, a person calls, and your staff spends the hour explaining that you are a different firm from the one in the ad. Read the message as if you had written it. Then decide, one person at a time, whether this is work you can actually take.

Frequently Asked Questions

What if the firm has not said who it takes?

Then every lead is a guess. Write the client and the service in the same words the site uses, and do that before anyone goes out to find people. A helper with only the word accounting will use a generic pitch, because that is all they were given.

Can the helper book the first meeting?

Not until someone at the firm has said yes to that person. A meeting for a client you would have turned down spends the hour you were trying to protect. The helper can gather the facts. You decide who gets the time.

What if their script is better than our page?

Hear it. Maybe the page is vague and the script noticed. Change the page yourself, then let the message follow. Do not let a new offer go out while the site still describes the old firm. The stranger will meet whichever version they see first.

How do you tell a useful inquiry from noise?

A useful one names work you lead with and a client you can take, and it asks for the facts your own form already asks for. Noise is a person who needed a different firm and was pointed at you anyway. A longer list does not change that.

What if we only pay when we accept the client?

Ask the board where you are licensed whether that payment is a commission or a referral fee, and whether you have to disclose it or decline it. Do not guess from the contract title. Get the answer before you agree to the price.

A short note each month on software, automation, and online presence. No recycled posts, and no pitch dressed up as advice.

Questions?

Tell us what is slowing the business down. We will say which of the work actually helps, and which of it can wait.